Position Papers




Santa Ynez Valley Alliance

News

Board of Supervisors Designates Mattei’s Tavern Santa Barbara County Historic Landmark

[03 November 2010] On Tuesday, November 2nd, the Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to designate Mattei’s Tavern as Historic Landmark number 47.

The Supervisors confirmed the designation consistent with the Historic Landmarks Advisory Committee (HLAC) action of September 13. The HLAC designated Mattei’s as County landmark, but the ninety-day designation would have lapsed if not confirmed by the BOS.

The Santa Ynez Valley Alliance nominated the site for Historic Landmark status almost 10 months ago, on January 13, 2010.

The Valley Alliance had been deeply troubled that the proposed construction of a large-scale resort at Mattei’s Tavern would dramatically impact the iconic character of the historic site of the former hotel, stage and rail terminal, restaurant, and gardens.

The Valley Alliance's meticulously researched, fifty-page peer-reviewed nomination document was consistent with Action HA-SYV-2.1 of the Santa Ynez Valley Community Plan which directs that, “The County and the community should continue to work to identify structures and places that qualify for nomination to Landmark Status and forward these requests to the County Historical Landmarks Commission.” The Valley Alliance is a non-profit organization which seeks to protect and preserve the agricultural, rural, and historic character of the Valley.

Eight notable institutions supported the designation, including the Pearl Chase Society, the Native Sons of the Golden West, the Santa Barbara Conservancy, and the Goleta Valley Historical Society. Californians from around the state and county wrote letters of support.

On May 10, 2010, the HLAC voted to pursue Landmark status and established a subcommittee to meet with representatives of Santa Rita Land and Vine LLC, the owners, to work out an agreement. The owners eventually agreed to the HLAC suggestions to "landmark" status prior to remodeling and demolition.

The landmark protection includes the historic elements of the Tavern itself, including the lobby, the bar, the glass-enclosed “Wicker Room,” the former stage office, a small dining room, and the upstairs hotel rooms. Apart from the exteriors, specific elements of the interiors are protected. Areas at the rear of the Tavern subject to more recent construction and revision, such as the kitchen, are not protected and are proposed for remodeling.

Also designated for protection are the water tower and base (known as the Tank Room), the historic exteriors of four cottages, and thirteen “character-defining” specimen trees located in the surrounding gardens. The existing Keenan-Hartley House moved to the site in 1998 is already a County Historic Landmark. The resolution adopted by the BOS recognizes the Tavern as "the most important historic landmark of the post-Gold Rush era in the Santa Ynez Valley." The only comparable historic structure in the Santa Ynez Valley is the Santa Iñes Mission, which is a National Historic Landmark.

The Valley Alliance wishes to thank all of those who made the landmarking possible, including the members of the HLAC, the Board of Supervisors, and especially the citizens of the Santa Ynez Valley who fought long and hard to preserve this legacy of the past. They deserve this.

Valley Candidates Speak to Voters

[01 October 2010] Local Valley candidates for Water Conservation District ID1 and the Santa Ynez Valley Union High School District Board of Trustees spoke at a forum sponsored by a coalition of local non-profit citizens groups. The forums were held on Tuesday, September 28 and Wednesday, September 29 from 7:00–9:00 pm at the Santa Ynez Valley Union High School Little Theater, 2975 E. Highway 246, Santa Ynez, CA to enhance public awareness of local voter issues and candidates. To view the forums, click on the links below.

Santa Ynez River Water Conservation District ID1
Board Candidates Voter Forum
Click here to view ID1 forum video


Santa Ynez Union Valley High School District
Board of Trustees Voter Forum Click here to view SYVUHSD Forum video

Both forums were sponsored by local non-profit organizations, including: the Santa Ynez Valley Alliance, Women's Environmental Watch, Santa Barbara Action Network, and the Citizen's Planning Association.

HLAC Designates Mattei's Tavern County Landmark #47

[13 September 2010] The Santa Barbara County Historic Landmarks Advisory Commission (HLAC) voted Monday morning, September 13, 2010, to designate the Mattei's Tavern in Los Olivos as Santa Barbara County Historic Landmark #47. The resolution for the designation had the consent of the property owners and passed with a unanimous 6-0 vote. This designation goes into effect immediately but will expire in 90 days unless the action is confirmed by the Board of Supervisors. The Board of Supervisors may confirm, modify or disapprove the designation within that period. The action of the Board of Supervisors is then final.

The Santa Ynez Valley Alliance nominated Mattei's Tavern for Landmark status in January and the HLAC voted to pursue Landmark status in May. At which time the HLAC established a subcommittee to discuss the issue with the property owners, establish the conditions that would apply and compose the resolution.

 

Santa Ynez Valley Alliance Holds Fourth Annual Membership Meeting

[12 September 2010] The Santa Ynez Valley Alliance held its fourth annual membership meeting on Sunday, Sept. 12 from 2:00 to 3:30 pm at the Los Olivos Grange. This year's keynote speaker was Jim Poett, a sixth-generation Santa Ynez Valley resident and rancher. Mr. Poett's talk was entitled, "Agriculturalists and Environmentalists: Opportunities to Work Together." More details and photos to be posted soon.

 

HLAC Votes to Pursue Landmark Status for Mattei's Tavern

[12 May 2010] The Santa Barbara County Historic Landmarks Advisory Commission (HLAC) met on Monday, May 10th, to consider the Santa Ynez Valley Alliance nomination of Mattei's Tavern for historic landmark status. On a 6-to-1 vote, the Commission voted to pursue landmark status for Mattei's, establishing a sub-committee of two commissioners to meet with the property owner in an attempt to work out the details of the nomination and bring back their results to the larger Commission. For background information on the effort to preserve Mattei's, see below.

 

Santa Ynez Valley Alliance Nominates Mattei’s Tavern for Historic Landmark Protection


Mattei's Tavern as it appeared in 1888.

[14 January 2010] At a press conference held Jan. 13, 2010, the Santa Ynez Valley Alliance formally announced that it was nominating Mattei’s Tavern in Los Olivos for designation as a Historical Landmark.  The nomination was submitted to the County’s Historic Landmarks Advisory Commission (HLAC) for consideration.

The nomination is consistent with the Santa Ynez Valley Community Plan, which speaks to community involvement in historic preservation:

HA-SYV-2: "Historic resources shall be protected and preserved to the maximum extent feasible."

Action HA-SYV-2.1: "The County and the community should continue to work to identify structures and places that qualify for nomination to landmark status and forward these requests to the County Historical Landmarks Commission."

On May 12, 1997 the Santa Barbara County Historical Landmark Advisory Committee voted unanimously "to designate the entire Mattei's Tavern property as a Place of Historical Merit"; however, the appropriate paperwork to finalize the designation was not completed by the owner. To this day, Mattei’s Tavern still cannot be found among the 68 historic places or landmarks recognized by the County.

“Like most people in the Santa Ynez Valley, we always thought that Mattei’s Tavern was an historic landmark. After all, following Mission Santa Ines, it is the second most recognized and beloved historic site in the Valley. We were shocked to learn that Mattei’s has no formal historic landmark status. And that is simply why we are here today, to ask the County’s Historic Landmarks Advisory Commission to recommend to the Board of Supervisors that the Mattei’s Tavern site be designated an historic landmark,” stated Mark Oliver, President of the Santa Ynez Valley Alliance.


Mattei's Tavern as it appears today.

Watch January 13, 2010 Press Conference
[Video running time: 36:51]

Links

 

Valley Resident Jody White Honored


SYVA Coordinator (2009), Mark Preston (left), with honored
SYVA board member emeritus, Jody White (right).

At its third annual meeting on September 13, 2009, the Santa Ynez Valley Alliance honored long-time activist and former Valley Alliance Board Member Jody White (above-right) with the Environmental Stewardship Award. "Having been part of preserving what is great about the Santa Ynez Valley for nearly three decades, Jody more than deserves this Award,” stated Board Member Gail Marshall.

 

Permit Streamlining

Several years ago the County formed a "Process Improvement Team" to look at ways that
the Planning Department processes and policies could be streamlined for greater ease and efficiency. Some of the changes which have subsequently been made have been positive, for example the reformatting of the zoning code and putting more information on their website that is "user friendly." However, many changes to the permitting process are "downshifting" the level of decisionmaker on land use permits. This results in the general public having little or no chance to participate in the process in a meaningful way. For example, someone building or remodeling a house used to have to go through a land use permit process which required the posting of the permit on the property as to what changes were being proposed. This gave the neighbors and other interested community members ten days to learn about the project and ask questions. If issues arose, a neighbor could appeal the decision. Now, with permit streamlining, in most cases there will be no posting of the permit and no opportunity for the neighborhood or surrounding community to know about what is to be constructed before it happens and no right to appeal the decision. This permit streamlining is being applied to many types of land use decisions in all zone districts, particularly residential and agricultural.

 

Get Your VA Shopping Bag!

Once again, this year I want to thank those in the Valley who have stepped forward to
support our mission. And once again, more than 100 of you have joined the effort to
keep the Valley rural, as we know it.

SYVA Board Treasurer, Donna Will (right), hands out VA
shopping bags at Solvang Farmers Market.

And even more, this year you can show your support for our community and the Valley Alliance by using our very own environmentally-friendly shopping bags. Made of recycled material and slightly larger than most bags, they’re ideal for shopping at the local farmer’s markets in Solvang and Los Olivos. Support your Valley farmers and businesses. Buy local and use your bag! — Mark Oliver, President